2023 National 5 Physics marking instructions

Source: Scottish Qualifications Authority (SQA) / Qualifications Scotland. This is a StemInteract HTML companion, not an official HTML edition. Selectable text is supplied alongside original page images. Use the images or original PDF for equations, powers, fractions, vector notation, tables and diagrams; text extraction cannot fully preserve mathematical layout.

Jump to a question

PDF page 1

Original 2023 National 5 Physics marking instructions, PDF page 1; open the image for mathematical layout and diagrams.
Original page image: preserves diagrams, equations, tables and symbols.
Selectable page text
National

                   Qualifications
                   2023

                           2023   Physics

                            National    5

                Finalised   Marking    Instructions

© Scottish Qualifications Authority 2023

These marking instructions have been prepared by examination teams for use by SQA appointed
markers when marking external course assessments. The information in this document may be
reproduced in support of SQA qualifications only on a noncommercial basis. If it is reproduced, SQA
must be clearly acknowledged as the source. If it is to be reproduced for any other purpose, written
permission must be obtained from permissions@sqa.org.uk.

PDF page 2

Original 2023 National 5 Physics marking instructions, PDF page 2; open the image for mathematical layout and diagrams.
Original page image: preserves diagrams, equations, tables and symbols.
Selectable page text
General marking principles for National 5 Physics

This information is provided to help you understand the general principles you must apply when
marking candidate responses to questions in this paper. These principles must be read in conjunction
with the detailed marking instructions, which identify the key features required in candidate
responses.

(a) Marks for each candidate response must always be assigned in line with these marking
    principles, the Physics: general marking principles (GMPs) (Physics: general marking principles -
    National 3 to Advanced Higher (sqa.org.uk)) and the detailed marking instructions for this
    assessment.

(b) Marking should always be positive. This means that, for each candidate response, marks are
    accumulated for the demonstration of relevant skills, knowledge and understanding: they are
    not deducted from a maximum on the basis of errors or omissions.

(c) If a specific candidate response does not seem to be covered by either the principles or detailed
    marking instructions, and you are uncertain how to assess it, you must seek guidance from your
    team leader.

(d) Where a candidate answers part of a question incorrectly and carries the incorrect answer
    forward in the following part, award marks if the incorrect answer has then been used correctly
    in the subsequent part or ‘follow-on’. (GMP 16)

(e) Award marks for non-standard symbols where the symbols are defined and the relationship is
    correct, or where the substitution shows that the relationship used is correct. This must be clear
    and unambiguous. (GMP 20)

(f) Award full marks for a correct final answer (including units if required) on its own, unless a
    numerical question specifically requires evidence of working to be shown, eg in a ‘show’
    question. (GMP 1)

(g) Award marks where a diagram or sketch conveys correctly the response required by the
    question. It will usually require clear and correct labels (or the use of standard symbols). (GMP
    19)

(h) Marks are allocated for knowledge of relevant relationships alone. Do not award a mark when a
    candidate writes down several relationships and does not select the correct one to continue
    with, for example by substituting values. (GMP 1c)

(i) Do not award marks if a ‘magic triangle’, eg , is the only statement in a candidate’s
                                                              V
    response. To gain the mark, the correct relationship must be stated eg V = IR or R = . (GMP
                                                               I
    2)
(j) In rounding to an expected number of significant figures, award the mark for correct answers
    that have up to two figures more or one figure less than the number in the data with the fewest
    significant figures. (GMP 6)
    (Note: the use of a recurrence dot, eg 0.6^{} , would imply an infinite number of significant
    figures and would therefore not be acceptable.)

                               page 02

PDF page 3

Original 2023 National 5 Physics marking instructions, PDF page 3; open the image for mathematical layout and diagrams.
Original page image: preserves diagrams, equations, tables and symbols.
Selectable page text
(k) The incorrect spelling of technical terms should usually be ignored and candidates should be
    awarded the relevant mark, provided that answers can be interpreted and understood without
    any doubt as to the meaning.
    Where there is ambiguity, do not award the mark. Two specific examples of this would be when
    the candidate uses a term:
       • that might be interpreted as reflection, refraction or diffraction, eg ‘defraction’
       • that might be interpreted as either fission or fusion, eg ‘fussion’
    The spelling of these words is similar, but the words have totally different meanings. If the
    spelling (or handwriting) in an answer makes it difficult for you to interpret a candidate’s
    intention, then do not award the mark. (GMP 22)

(l) Marks are awarded only for a valid response to the question asked. For example, in response to
    questions that ask candidates to:

    •  identify, name, give, or state, they need only name or present in brief form.
    •  describe, they must provide a statement or structure of characteristics and/or features.
    •  explain, they must relate cause and effect and/or make relationships between things clear.
    •  determine or calculate, they must determine a number from given facts, figures or
       information.

    •  estimate, they must determine an approximate value for something.
    •  justify, they must give reasons to support their suggestions or conclusions, eg this might be
       by identifying an appropriate relationship and the effect of changing variables.
    •  show that, they must use physics (and mathematics) to prove something, eg a given value.
       All steps, including the stated answer, must be shown.
    •  predict, they must suggest what may happen based on available information.

    •  suggest, they must apply their knowledge and understanding of physics to a new situation. A
       number of responses are acceptable: award marks for any suggestions that are supported by
       knowledge and understanding of physics.
    •  use your knowledge of physics or aspect of physics to comment on, they must apply their
       skills, knowledge and understanding to respond appropriately to the problem/situation
       presented, for example by making a statement of principle(s) involved and/or a relationship
       or equation, and applying these to respond to the problem/situation. Candidates are given
       credit for the breadth and/or depth of their conceptual understanding.

                               page 03

PDF page 4

Original 2023 National 5 Physics marking instructions, PDF page 4; open the image for mathematical layout and diagrams.
Original page image: preserves diagrams, equations, tables and symbols.
Selectable page text
Common issues with candidate responses

When marking National 5 Physics, there are some common issues that arise when considering
candidates’ answers.

There is often a range of acceptable responses that would sensibly answer a particular question.
However, it is often difficult to anticipate all correct or partially correct responses to questions.

The detailed marking instructions contain ideal answers, and examples of other acceptable answers,
which offer guidance for interpreting candidates’ responses. They may also contain advice on answers
that are not acceptable, or only attract partial marks.

Units

Do not penalise use of upper/lower case when the abbreviated version is given, as long as it can be
clearly identified, eg DB, sV, hZ, bq.

However, take care to ensure the unit has the correct prefix, eg for an answer t = 0.005 seconds,
t = 5 ms is acceptable but t = 5 Ms is not.

Where a candidate makes multiple unit errors or conversion errors/omissions in any part of a question,
penalise once only. For example, when calculating speed from distance and time, and the answer is
required to be in ms⁻¹.

If  d = 4 km and t = 2 minutes

                       d
                     v=      (1)
                        t
                       400
                     v=      (1)
                        2
                     v=200   (0)
Although the candidate has made three unit errors, (not correctly converted distance or time and has
omitted the final unit), do not award the final mark only.

Some common units often attract incorrect abbreviations in answers to numerical questions.
When the abbreviation can be confused with a different unit then the final mark cannot be awarded,
eg sec or secs as an abbreviation for seconds is not acceptable.

 Common units and abbreviations
 Acceptable unit and abbreviation unacceptable version
 second, s                       sec, secs
 hours, h                        hr, hrs
 ampere, amp, amps, A, a
 metres per second, m s⁻¹, m/s   mps, m/s⁻¹
 metres per second per second, m s⁻², m/s² m/s/s, mpsps, m/s⁻²
 joules per kilogram per degree celsius,
                                 J/kg/ºC
 J kg⁻¹ ºC⁻¹, J/kg ºC

                               page 04

PDF page 5

Original 2023 National 5 Physics marking instructions, PDF page 5; open the image for mathematical layout and diagrams.
Original page image: preserves diagrams, equations, tables and symbols.
Selectable page text
Standard form

Where a candidate fails to express an answer in standard form correctly, treat it as an arithmetic
error and do not award the final mark. For example:

For an answer t = 400 000 s, then t = 4×10⁵ s would be correct but t = 4⁵ s would be treated as an
arithmetic error. (GMP 10)

Incorrect answer carried forward (GMP 16)
Do not apply a further penalty where a candidate carries forward an incorrect answer to part of a
question, and uses that incorrect answer correctly:
  •  within that part of the question, eg from (a)(i) to (a)(ii)
  •  or to the next part of the question, eg from (a) to (b).

Similarly, if a candidate has selected the wrong value in a question that requires a data value, then
award full marks in the subsequent answer for a correct response that uses either the candidate’s
wrong value or the correct data value. For example:

(a)  State the speed of microwaves in air.
     Candidate’s answer: 240 m s⁻¹. This answer would attract zero marks.

(b)  Calculate the distance travelled by these microwaves in 0.34 seconds.
     The candidate may use either the value given in part (a) or the correct value for the speed,
     and could gain full marks if correctly completed.

Where an incorrect answer may be carried forward, this is indicated in the additional guidance column
of the detailed marking instructions by the comment ‘or consistent with part...’.

Standard three marker

The examples below set out how to apportion marks to answers requiring calculations. These are the
‘standard three marker’ type of questions.
Award full marks for a correct answer to a numerical question, even if the steps are not shown
explicitly, unless it specifically requires evidence of working to be shown.

For some questions requiring numerical calculations, there may be alternative methods
(eg alternative relationships) that would lead to a correct answer.

Sometimes, a question requires a calculation that does not fit into the ‘standard three marker’ type of
response. In these cases, the detailed marking instructions will contain guidance for marking the
question.

When marking partially correct answers, apportion individual marks as shown over the page.

                               page 05

PDF page 6

Original 2023 National 5 Physics marking instructions, PDF page 6; open the image for mathematical layout and diagrams.
Original page image: preserves diagrams, equations, tables and symbols.
Selectable page text
Example of a ‘standard three marker’ question
The current in a resistor is 1.5 amperes when the potential difference across it is 7.5 volts.
Calculate the resistance of the resistor. (3 marks)

          Example response Mark and comment

       1. V = IR          1 mark: relationship
          7.5 = 1.5R      1 mark: substitution

          R = 5.0 Ω       1 mark: correct answer

       2. 5.0 Ω           3 marks: correct answer
       3. 5.0             2 marks: unit missing

       4. 4.0 Ω           0 marks: no evidence, wrong answer

       5. __ Ω            0 marks: no working or final answer
       6.    V  7.5
          R =  =   =4.0 Ω 2 marks: arithmetic error
             I  1.5
       7.    V
          R =  =4.0 Ω     1 mark: relationship only
             I
       8.   V
          R=  =__Ω        1 mark: relationship only
             I
       9.    V  7.5       2 marks: relationship and substitution, no final
          R = =    = __Ω
             I  1.5       answer
      10.    V  7.5
          R = =    =4.0   2 marks: relationship and substitution, wrong answer
             I  1.5
      11.    V  1.5
          R=  =   =5.0 Ω  1 mark: relationship but wrong substitution
             I  7.5
      12.    V  75
          R=  =   =5.0 Ω  1 mark: relationship but wrong substitution
             I  1.5
      13.    I  1.5
          R=  =   =5.0 Ω  0 marks: wrong relationship
             V  7.5
      14. V = IR
          7.5 = 1.5 × R
          R = 0.2 Ω       2 marks: relationship and substitution, arithmetic
                          error
      15. V = IR
             I  1.5
          R=  =   =0.2 Ω  1 mark: relationship correct but wrong
             V  7.5       rearrangement of symbols

                               page 06

PDF page 7

Section 1, Question 1Section 1, Question 2Section 1, Question 3Section 1, Question 4Section 1, Question 5Section 1, Question 6Section 1, Question 7Section 1, Question 8Section 1, Question 9Section 1, Question 10Section 1, Question 11Section 1, Question 12Section 1, Question 13Section 1, Question 14Section 1, Question 15Section 1, Question 16Section 1, Question 17Section 1, Question 18Section 1, Question 19Section 1, Question 20Section 1, Question 21Section 1, Question 22Section 1, Question 23Section 1, Question 24Section 1, Question 25
Original 2023 National 5 Physics marking instructions, PDF page 7; open the image for mathematical layout and diagrams.
Original page image: preserves diagrams, equations, tables and symbols.
Selectable page text
Marking instructions for each question

Section 1

  Question   Answer      Mark

     1.         D         1

     2.         D         1
     3.         C         1

     4.         D         1

     5.         B         1

     6.         D         1
     7.         A         1

     8.         D         1

     9.         E         1

    10.         C         1

    11.         D         1
    12.         A         1

    13.         C         1

    14.         E         1

    15.         C         1

    16.         C         1
    17.         B         1

    18.         B         1

    19.         A         1

    20.         C         1
    21.         B         1

    22.         E         1

    23.         A         1

    24.         E         1

    25.         B         1

                               page 07

PDF page 8

Section 2, Question 1
Original 2023 National 5 Physics marking instructions, PDF page 8; open the image for mathematical layout and diagrams.
Original page image: preserves diagrams, equations, tables and symbols.
Selectable page text
Section 2

                                        Max
   Question       Expected response               Additional guidance
                                       mark
 1.  (a) (i) Using Pythagoras:          2   Ignore any direction stated in the
                                            final answer in this part.
            resultant² = 24² + 63² (1)
            resultant = 67 m       (1)      If clear arithmetic error shown in
                                            38 – 14 = 24 or 74 – 11 = 63 then MAX
                                            (1) mark for substitution consistent
            Using scale diagram:            with arithmetic error.
                                            No requirement for arrows to be
                                            shown on diagram to calculate the
                                            magnitude of displacement.

                                            Regardless of method, if a candidate
                                            shows a vector diagram (or a
                        OR
                                            representation of a vector diagram
                                            ie a triangle with no arrows) and the
                                            vectors have been added
                                            incorrectly, eg head-to-head then
                                            MAX (1).

            vectors to scale       (1)
                                            Accept:
            resultant = 67 m       (1)      70 m
            (allow ± 2 m tolerance)         67.4 m
                                            67.42 m

                               page 08

PDF page 9

Original 2023 National 5 Physics marking instructions, PDF page 9; open the image for mathematical layout and diagrams.
Original page image: preserves diagrams, equations, tables and symbols.
Selectable page text
Max
  Question       Expected response               Additional guidance
                                      mark
1.  (a) (ii) Using trigonometry:       2   Regardless of method, if a candidate
                                           shows a vector diagram (or a
                63                         representation of a vector diagram
           tanθ =                 (1)
                                           ie a triangle with no arrows) and the
                24
                                           vectors have been added
           (θ = 69º)                       incorrectly, eg head-to-head then
                                           MAX (1).
           direction = 291        (1)
                                           Alternative methods:
           Using scale diagram:
                                                 24
                                            tanθ =                (1)
                                                 63
                                           (θ = 21º)
                                           direction = 291        (1)
                       OR
                                           OR
                                           Use of resultant value (and
                                           appropriate trigonometry) consistent
                                           with (a)(i),eg
                                                 63       24
           vectors to scale       (1)       sinθ = or sinθ =
                                                67        67
           direction = 291        (1)
           (allow ± 2º tolerance)          Ignore the degree symbol if the
                                           direction is stated as a bearing.
                                           Accept:
                                           21º North of West
                                           69º West of North

                                           Can obtain first mark for scale
                                           diagram method from suitable
                                           diagram in part (a)(i) if not drawn in
                                           this part. However, the candidate
                                           must attempt an answer in this part.

                                           Ignore any magnitude stated in the
                                           final answer in this part.
                                           Do not accept incorrect statements
                                           of trig functions at substitution
                                           stage, eg
                                                24
                                            tan =
                                                63

                                           Accept:
                                           70º W of N  290
                                           69.1º W of N 290.9
                                           69.15º W of N 290.85

                              page 09

PDF page 10

Original 2023 National 5 Physics marking instructions, PDF page 10; open the image for mathematical layout and diagrams.
Original page image: preserves diagrams, equations, tables and symbols.
Selectable page text
Max
  Question       Expected response               Additional guidance
                                      mark
1.  (b) (i) s =vt                 (1)  3   Or consistent with (a)(i) and/or
                                           (a)(ii)
           67 =v×31               (1)
            v =2.2 ms⁻¹ at 291    (1)      Bar not required above v.
                                           Accept    provided it is followed
                                           by a substitution of the value for
                                           displace𝑑𝑑m=en𝑣𝑣t𝑣𝑣.

                                           Direction required for final mark

                                           Accept:
                                           2
                                           2.16
                                           2.161

        (ii) distance is greater (than 2   Or by calculation of speed showing
           displacement)          (1)      correct substitution for distance (1)
                                           and time (1)
           same time for both     (1)
                                           ie
                                               d
                                            v=
                                               t
                                               137
                                            v=             (1)+(1)
                                               31
                                            (v=4.4 ms⁻¹)
                                           Note: any arithmetic, rounding or
                                           unit error in this calculation MAX (1)

    (c) (i) E_{P} = mgh           (1)  2   ‘Show’ question
            E_{P} =0.0025×9.8×7.5 (1)

            E_{P} =0.18 J                  Final answer of 0.18 J including
                                           unit, must be shown or MAX (1)

                              page 10

PDF page 11

Original 2023 National 5 Physics marking instructions, PDF page 11; open the image for mathematical layout and diagrams.
Original page image: preserves diagrams, equations, tables and symbols.
Selectable page text
Max
  Question       Expected response               Additional guidance
                                      mark
1.  (c) (ii)    1                      3   Accept:
             Eₖ = mv²             (1)
                                           10
                2
                                           12.0
                1
           0.18= ×0.0025×v²       (1)      12.00
                2
             v =12 ms⁻¹           (1)      Alternative method 1:
                                            v= 2gh       (1)
                                            v= 2×9.8×7.5 (1)
                                            v=12 ms⁻¹    (1)
                                           Alternative method 2:
                                                    mgh= ₂¹mv²   (1)
                                            0.0025×9.8×7.5= ₂¹×0.0025×v² (1)
                                                      v=12 ms⁻¹  (1)
                                           Accept for these alternative
                                           methods:
                                           10
                                           12.1
                                           12.12
       (iii) energy lost (as heat) due to air 1 Do not accept:
           resistance/friction             energy lost alone
                                           air resistance/friction alone

                              page 11

PDF page 12

Section 2, Question 2
Original 2023 National 5 Physics marking instructions, PDF page 12; open the image for mathematical layout and diagrams.
Original page image: preserves diagrams, equations, tables and symbols.
Selectable page text
Max
  Question       Expected response               Additional guidance
                                      mark
2.  (a)    correct curved path shown   1   Do not accept indication of curve
                                           rising above horizontal
    (b) (i)       v−u                  3   Accept:
               a =                (1)
                                           5
                   t
                                           5.19
           (−)9.8 =
                  v−0
                                  (1)      5.194
                  0.53
                                  (1)
              v = (−)5.2 ms⁻¹              Accept:
                                               Δv
                                            a =
                                               t
                                           Do not accept a response starting
                                           with:
                                                       v
                                            v =at or a =
                                                       t
        (ii)                           2   or consistent with (b)(i)
                                           independent marks
           correct shape - straight line with
           positive gradient starting at origin
                                  (1)

           graph ends at (0.53, 5.2) (1)

                              page 12

PDF page 13

Original 2023 National 5 Physics marking instructions, PDF page 13; open the image for mathematical layout and diagrams.
Original page image: preserves diagrams, equations, tables and symbols.
Selectable page text
Max
  Question       Expected response               Additional guidance
                                      mark
2.  (b) (iii) s =area under graph (1)  3   or consistent with (b)(i) or (b)(ii)
              1
                                  (1)
           s = ×0.53×5.2                   If incorrect substitution then MAX
              2
                                           (1) for implied relationship
                                  (1)
           s =1.4 m
                                           Accept:
                                           1
                                           1.38
                                           1.378
                                           Accept:
                                            s =vt ord =vt
                                           Accept:
                                            s=vt ord =vt
                                           provided it is followed by a
                                           substitution of the average vertical
                                           velocity
                                           Alternative method:

                                                mgh= ₂¹mv²      (1)
                                            m×9.8×h= ₂¹×m×5.2²  (1)

                                                  h=1.4 m       (1)

                                           Note: m may be cancelled or a value
                                           substituted
                                           Accept for this method: 1.380

    (c) (i) F =54−22              (1)  4   Calculation of unbalanced force may
                                           be implied by correct substitution.
           (F =32 N)
                                           If no attempt to calculate
            F =ma                 (1)      unbalanced force then MAX (1) for
                                           relationship.
            32=74×a               (1)
            a =0.43 ms⁻²          (1)
                                           If clear arithmetic error in
                                           calculation of unbalanced force then
                                           MAX (3).
                                           Accept:
                                           0.4
                                           0.432

                                           0.4324
        (ii) reduces friction/air resistance (1) 1 Accept:
                                           wind resistance

                                           Do not accept:
                                           no friction/no air resistance
                                           ‘slipstreaming’ alone

                                           ‘resistance’ alone

                              page 13

PDF page 14

Section 2, Question 3
Original 2023 National 5 Physics marking instructions, PDF page 14; open the image for mathematical layout and diagrams.
Original page image: preserves diagrams, equations, tables and symbols.
Selectable page text
Max
  Question       Expected response               Additional guidance
                                      mark
3.  (a)    Astra 1KR              (1)  2   MUST JUSTIFY

           it is a geostationary satellite Satellite correct + justification
                                           correct (2)
           OR
                                           Satellite correct + justification
                                           incomplete (1)
           it has an orbital period of 24 hours
                                           Satellite correct + justification
                                           incorrect (wrong physics) (0)
           OR
                                           Satellite correct + no justification
           it is at an orbital altitude of attempted (0)
           36 000 km              (1)
                                           Incorrect or no satellite stated,
                                           regardless of justification (0)
   (b)     W =mg                  (1)  3   Accept:
                                           30
           W =3.5 × 7.7           (1)
                                           27.0
           W =27 N
                                  (1)      26.95
                                           Do not accept: F =ma
   (c)     any single value greater than 101 1 Unit required
           minutes and less than 676 minutes
                                           Can be expressed in other units of
                                           time, eg seconds or hours
                                           Do not accept an answer that
                                           includes/implies a range of values

                              page 14

PDF page 15

Section 2, Question 4
Original 2023 National 5 Physics marking instructions, PDF page 15; open the image for mathematical layout and diagrams.
Original page image: preserves diagrams, equations, tables and symbols.
Selectable page text
Max
  Question       Expected response               Additional guidance
                                      mark
4.         Award 3 marks where the candidate 3 Candidates may use a variety of
           has demonstrated a good         physics arguments to answer this
           understanding of the physics    question.
           involved. They show a good
                                           Award marks based on candidates
           comprehension of the physics of the
                                           demonstrating overall good,
           situation and provide a logically
                                           reasonable, limited, or no
           correct answer to the question
                                           understanding.
           posed. This type of response might
           include a statement of the principles
           involved, a relationship or an
           equation, and the application of
           these to respond to the problem. The
           answer does not need to be
           ‘excellent’ or ‘complete’ for the
           candidate to gain full marks.
           Award 2 marks where the candidate
           has demonstrated a reasonable
           understanding of the physics
           involved. They make some
           statement(s) that are relevant to the
           situation, showing that they have
           understood the problem.
           Award 1 mark where the candidate
           has demonstrated a limited
           understanding of the physics
           involved. They make some
           statement(s) that are relevant to the
           situation, showing that they have
           understood at least a little of the
           physics within the problem.
           Award 0 marks where the candidate
           has not demonstrated an
           understanding of the physics
           involved. There is no evidence that
           they have recognised the area of
           physics involved, or they have not
           given any statement of a relevant
           physics principle. Award this mark
           also if the candidate merely restates
           the physics given in the question.

                              page 15

PDF page 16

Section 2, Question 5
Original 2023 National 5 Physics marking instructions, PDF page 16; open the image for mathematical layout and diagrams.
Original page image: preserves diagrams, equations, tables and symbols.
Selectable page text
Max
  Question       Expected response               Additional guidance
                                      mark
5.  (a)    not affected by weather     1   Accept any other reasonable answer
           OR
                                           Accept:
           no (distortion from) atmosphere
                                           to see further
           OR
                                           Do not accept:
           no light pollution
                                           ‘clearer’ alone
           OR                              closer
                                           (neither would negate a correct
           can use telescope during the day
                                           response)
                                           Apply +/- rule for surplus answers
    (b)    hydrogen and calcium        1   Must have both
                                           Any additional elements (0) marks
                                           Accept correct chemical symbols
    (c)    d =vt                  (1)  2   ‘Show’ question
                                           Accept use of d = st for relationship,
           d =3.0×10⁸×
                                           provided use is clarified by
                                  (1)
              (343×365.25×24×60×60)
                                           substitution.
           d =3.2×10¹⁸ m
                                           Calculation can be carried out in
                                           steps, but all steps must be shown
                                           for the substitution mark to be
                                           awarded.
                                           Final answer of 3.2 × 10¹⁸ m,
                                           including unit, must be shown or
                                           MAX (1).
                                           Accept use of 365 days

                              page 16

PDF page 17

Section 2, Question 6
Original 2023 National 5 Physics marking instructions, PDF page 17; open the image for mathematical layout and diagrams.
Original page image: preserves diagrams, equations, tables and symbols.
Selectable page text
Max
  Question       Expected response               Additional guidance
                                      mark
6.  (a)    Total R=36+24          (1)  4   Calculation of total resistance may
                                           be implied by correct substitution.
                (=60 Ω)
            V = IR                (1)
                                           If no attempt to calculate total
           12= I ×60              (1)      resistance then MAX (1) for
            I =0.20 A             (1)      relationship.
                                           If clear arithmetic error in
                                           calculation of total resistance then
                                           MAX (3).

                                           Alternative methods:
                                           (1) for calculation of total resistance
                                           (1) for all required relationships
                                           (1) for all substitutions
                                           (1) for final answer including unit

                                           Accept:
                                           0.2
                                           0.200
                                           0.2000

    (b) (i) 1   1  1                   4   Do not accept wrong relationship eg
              =  +
            R_{T} R₁ R₂           (1)       1   1  1
                                               =  +  +R₃
            1   1  1                        R T R₁ R₂
              =  +                (1)
            R_{T} 36 36                    OR
                                                1  1
           (R_{T} =18 Ω)                    R_{T} = +
                                               R₁ R₂
                                           OR
            R_{T} =18+24          (1)
                                            1    1  1  1
            R_{T} =42 Ω           (1)          =  +  +        (0) marks
                                            R   R₁ R₂  R₃
                                              T
                                           Accept imprecise working towards a
                                           value for parallel resistance.
                                            1
                                              =
                                                1
                                                 +
                                                   1
                                                    =
                                                      1
                                                        +
                                                         1
                                                           =18Ω
                                            R_{T} R₁ R₂ 36 36
                                                         accept
                                           If arithmetic error in parallel
                                           resistance calculation, can still
                                           access mark for adding the 24 Ω
                                           resistance, ie MAX (3).
                              page 17

PDF page 18

Original 2023 National 5 Physics marking instructions, PDF page 18; open the image for mathematical layout and diagrams.
Original page image: preserves diagrams, equations, tables and symbols.
Selectable page text
Max
  Question       Expected response               Additional guidance
                                      mark
6.  (b) (ii) (Ammeter reading will be) greater 2 or consistent with (a) and (b)(i)
                                  (1)
                                           MUST JUSTIFY
           Total circuit resistance will be less
                                           First mark can only be awarded if a
                                  (1)
                                           justification is attempted.
                                           Effect correct + justification correct
                                           (2)
                                           Effect correct + justification
                                           incomplete (1)
                                           Effect correct + justification
                                           incorrect (wrong physics) (0)

                                           Effect correct + no justification
                                           attempted (0)
                                           Incorrect or no effect stated
                                           regardless of justification (0)

                                           It must be clear that it is the
                                           resistance of the whole circuit that
                                           is less.

                                           If candidate tries to justify this by
                                           calculation, then the substitution
                                           must be correct or (0) marks.

                                           Note: any rounding error in the
                                           calculation would be treated in the
                                           same way as an incomplete
                                           justification, so the mark for the
                                           effect can still be awarded

                              page 18

PDF page 19

Section 2, Question 7
Original 2023 National 5 Physics marking instructions, PDF page 19; open the image for mathematical layout and diagrams.
Original page image: preserves diagrams, equations, tables and symbols.
Selectable page text
Max
  Question       Expected response               Additional guidance
                                      mark
7.  (a) (i) Suitable scales, labels, and units (1) 3 A non-linear scale on either axis
                                           prevents access to any marks (0)
           All points plotted accurately to ±
           half a division        (1)      Allow broken axes from origin (with
                                           or without symbol), but scale must
           Best fit curve         (1)      be linear across data range.

                                           A bar chart can obtain MAX (1) for
                                           scales, labels, and units.

                                           Axes can be transposed.

        (ii) 74 × 10⁻¹² C         (1)  1   Must be consistent with the line the
                                           candidate has drawn.

                                           If the candidate has not shown a
                                           curve or line in (b)(i) this mark
                                           cannot be accessed.

                                           If the candidate has used a non-
                                           linear scale in (b)(i) this mark
                                           cannot be accessed.

                                           ± half a division tolerance

    (b)    Any two of the following for (1) 2 Apply +/- rule for surplus answers
           mark each:
                                           Do not accept:
           Repeat measurements and average ‘repeat measurements’ alone
                                           ‘more readings’ alone
           Repeat measurements to identify
           outliers/rogue points
           Increase the range of distances
           Increase the number of different
           distances

                              page 19

PDF page 20

Section 2, Question 8
Original 2023 National 5 Physics marking instructions, PDF page 20; open the image for mathematical layout and diagrams.
Original page image: preserves diagrams, equations, tables and symbols.
Selectable page text
Max
  Question       Expected response               Additional guidance
                                      mark
8.  (a) (i) Eₕ =cmΔT              (1)  3   Value of ΔT may be substituted
                                           directly as 210 ºC.
           Eₕ =532×1.90×10⁻²×(235−25) (1)
           Eₕ =2120 J             (1)      If clear arithmetic error in
                                           calculation of ΔT then MAX (2).

                                           Accept:
                                           2100
                                           2123
                                           2122.7

        (ii) Heat (energy) lost to the     Do not accept ‘heat loss’ alone – it
                                       1
           surroundings.                   must be clear where it is going.
    (b)    different (specific) heat capacity (1) 2 Accept:
                                           different (thermal) conductivity
           different mass         (1)
                                           different rate of heat loss
                                           Must indicate a change.

                                           Apply +/- rule for surplus answers

                              page 20

PDF page 21

Section 2, Question 9
Original 2023 National 5 Physics marking instructions, PDF page 21; open the image for mathematical layout and diagrams.
Original page image: preserves diagrams, equations, tables and symbols.
Selectable page text
Max
  Question       Expected response               Additional guidance
                                      mark
9. (a)  (i) Force per unit area        1   Do not accept:
                                              F          force
                                            p=  or pressure = alone
                                              A          area
                                           Accept:
                                           Force per m².
       (ii)         p₁V₁= p₂V₂    (1)  3   Accept:

           101×10³×2.3×10⁻³ =92×10³×V₂ (1) 3 × 10⁻³
                                  (1)      2.53 × 10⁻³
                     V₂ =2.5×10⁻³m³
                                           2.525 × 10⁻³
       (iii) The (gas) particles collide with the 1 Ignore any extraneous information.
           walls (of the crisp packet). (1)
                                           Accept ‘atoms’/’molecules’ in place
                                           of ‘particles’
   (b)         H                       3   Accept:
            H  =                 (1)
                                           20
                t
                                           21.0
                H
           6.0 =                  (1)      21.00
               3.5
            H =21 μSv
                                  (1)      Treat conversion of time to minutes
                                           or seconds as a unit conversion
                                           error.

                              page 21

PDF page 22

Section 2, Question 10
Original 2023 National 5 Physics marking instructions, PDF page 22; open the image for mathematical layout and diagrams.
Original page image: preserves diagrams, equations, tables and symbols.
Selectable page text
Max
  Question       Expected response               Additional guidance
                                      mark
10. (a)       0.015                     4   Alternative method:
           t =                    (1)        d =vt                 (1)
               2
            =( 0.0075 s)                     d =340×0.015          (1)
                                            (d =5.1 m)
           d =vt                  (1)
                                               5.1
           d =340×0.0075          (1)       d =                    (1)
                                               2
           d =2.6 m               (1)
                                            d =2.6 m               (1)
                                            The mark for division of time
                                            or distance by two is an
                                            independent mark.
                                            It is incorrect physics to divide
                                            the speed by two.

                                            Accept:
                                            3
                                            2.55
                                            2.550
    (b) (i)    N                        2   ‘Show’ question
            f =                   (1)
               t
                  9
            f =                   (1)
               2.0×10⁻⁴
                                            Final answer of 45 000 Hz (or its
            f = 45 000 Hz                   numerical equivalent) must be
                                            shown, otherwise MAX (1)
                                            Alternative method:
                                               1
                                            f =              (1)
                                               T
                                                  1
                                            f =              (1)
                                               (     )
                                                2.0×10⁻⁴
                                                  9
                                            f = 45000 Hz
                                            For the second mark to be awarded
                                            it must be shown how the period is
                                            calculated.
        (ii) Speed (of sound in air) is the same 1
           OR
           The distance is the same

                              page 22

PDF page 23

Section 2, Question 11
Original 2023 National 5 Physics marking instructions, PDF page 23; open the image for mathematical layout and diagrams.
Original page image: preserves diagrams, equations, tables and symbols.
Selectable page text
Max
  Question       Expected response               Additional guidance
                                      mark
11. (a)    P: ultraviolet/UV            1   Both required
           Q: infrared/IR

    (b)    Radio (waves)          (1)   2   ‘Justify’ question

           Have the longest wavelength (1)  Accept:
                                            lowest frequency

                                            Do not accept:
                                            ‘longest’ alone
                                            ‘largest’ alone

    (c) (i)     v= fλ             (1)   2   ‘Show’ question
        (A)
           3.0×10⁸ =2.42×10⁹×λ    (1)
                                            Final answer of 0.12 m must be
                λ=0.12 m
                                            shown, otherwise MAX (1)
        (i) microwaves                  1
        (B)
        (ii)      E               (1)   3   Accept:
        (A)
               D=
                                            2 × 10⁻⁵
                  m
                                            2.25 × 10⁻⁵
                  E               (1)
           5.0×10⁻⁶ =                       2.250 × 10⁻⁵
                  4.5
                                  (1)
                E=2.3×10⁻⁵ J
        (ii) H =Dwᵣ               (1)   3   Accept:
        (B)                                 5 × 10⁻⁶
           H =5.0×10⁻⁶×1          (1)
                                            5.00 × 10⁻⁶
           H =5.0×10⁻⁶ Sv         (1)       5.000 × 10⁻⁶

                              page 23

PDF page 24

Section 2, Question 12
Original 2023 National 5 Physics marking instructions, PDF page 24; open the image for mathematical layout and diagrams.
Original page image: preserves diagrams, equations, tables and symbols.
Selectable page text
Max
  Question       Expected response               Additional guidance
                                      mark
12.        Award 3 marks where the candidate 3 Candidates may use a variety of
           has demonstrated a good         physics arguments to answer this
           understanding of the physics    question.
           involved. They show a good
                                           Award marks based on candidates
           comprehension of the physics of the
                                           demonstrating overall good,
           situation and provide a logically
                                           reasonable, limited, or no
           correct answer to the question
                                           understanding.
           posed. This type of response might
           include a statement of the principles
           involved, a relationship or an
           equation, and the application of
           these to respond to the problem.
           The answer does not need to be
           ‘excellent’ or ‘complete’ for the
           candidate to gain full marks.
           Award 2 marks where the candidate
           has demonstrated a reasonable
           understanding of the physics
           involved. They make some
           statement(s) that are relevant to the
           situation, showing that they have
           understood the problem.
           Award 1 mark where the candidate
           has demonstrated a limited
           understanding of the physics
           involved. They make some
           statement(s) that are relevant to the
           situation, showing that they have
           understood at least a little of the
           physics within the problem.
           Award 0 marks where the candidate
           has not demonstrated an
           understanding of the physics
           involved. There is no evidence that
           they have recognised the area of
           physics involved, or they have not
           given any statement of a relevant
           physics principle. Award this mark
           also if the candidate merely restates
           the physics given in the question.

                              page 24

PDF page 25

Section 2, Question 13
Original 2023 National 5 Physics marking instructions, PDF page 25; open the image for mathematical layout and diagrams.
Original page image: preserves diagrams, equations, tables and symbols.
Selectable page text
Max
  Question       Expected response               Additional guidance
                                      mark
13. (a)    Y                      (1)  3   ‘Justify’ question – must have
                                           correct source identified or (0)
                                           marks
           Sheet of paper absorbs alpha
           radiation, (reducing the count
           rate).                 (1)
                                           Can also be justified by explaining
           (8 mm of) lead absorbs (some of why it cannot be source X or source
           the) gamma radiation, (reducing the Z. (1) mark for each source
           count rate further).            explained correctly.
           OR
                                           Must associate absorber with type of
           (Some) gamma radiation is able to radiation for justification marks.
           penetrate (8 mm of) lead
           OR
                                           Do not accept:
           The gamma radiation is able to  (8 mm of) lead absorbs/blocks all
           penetrate the (3mm of) aluminium gamma
           OR
           (Source) Y is the only source with a
           (significant) reduction in count rate
           due to paper           (1)
    (b) (i) When an (uncharged) atom gains or 1
           loses an electron/electrons.

           OR
           When an (uncharged) atom gains an
           electron/electrons.

           OR
           When an (uncharged) atom loses an
           electron/electrons.

                              page 25

PDF page 26

Original 2023 National 5 Physics marking instructions, PDF page 26; open the image for mathematical layout and diagrams.
Original page image: preserves diagrams, equations, tables and symbols.
Selectable page text
Max
  Question       Expected response               Additional guidance
                                      mark
13. (b) (ii) alpha (radiation)    (1)  2   MUST JUSTIFY
                                           First mark can only be awarded if a
           Alpha radiation only has a short
                                           justification is attempted.
           range (in air)
                                           Effect correct + justification correct
           OR
                                           (2)
           Fewer alpha particles would reach
           the spark counter at increased  Effect correct + justification
           distance.              (1)      incomplete (1)
                                           Effect correct + justification
                                           incorrect (wrong physics) (0)
                                           Effect correct + no justification
                                           attempted (0)
                                           Incorrect or no effect stated
                                           regardless of justification (0)
                                           Responses only in terms of the
                                           ionisation effect of alpha are
                                           incomplete.

                              page 26

PDF page 27

Original 2023 National 5 Physics marking instructions, PDF page 27; open the image for mathematical layout and diagrams.
Original page image: preserves diagrams, equations, tables and symbols.
Selectable page text
Max
  Question       Expected response               Additional guidance
                                      mark
13. (b) (iii) Q = It              (1)  4   Alternative method 1:
                                                          60
           Q =0.12×10⁻⁶×60        (1)       time for one spark = (1)
                                                          96
           (
            Q =7.2×10⁻⁶ C
                      )
                                            ( t =0.625 s)
           for one spark:
              7.2×10⁻⁶            (1)       Q= It              (1)
           Q=
               96                           Q=0.12×10⁻⁶×0.625  (1)
                                  (1)
           Q=7.5×10⁻⁸ C
                                            Q=7.5×10⁻⁸ C       (1)
                                           Alternative method 2:
                                            number of sparks in one second
                                             96
                                            =  (=1.6)         (1)
                                             60
                                            calculation of charge in one second
                                            Q= It             (1)
                                            (          )
                                            Q=0.12×10⁻⁶×1
                                            (          )
                                            Q=0.12×10⁻⁶ C
                                            0.12×10⁻⁶
                                                              (1)
                                              1.6
                                            =7.5×10⁻⁸ C        (1)
                                           Division of the current by the
                                           number of sparks and then
                                           multiplying by the time is wrong
                                           physics, MAX (1) for relationship

                              page 27

PDF page 28

Section 2, Question 14
Original 2023 National 5 Physics marking instructions, PDF page 28; open the image for mathematical layout and diagrams.
Original page image: preserves diagrams, equations, tables and symbols.
Selectable page text
Max
   Question       Expected response               Additional guidance
                                       mark
14. (a) (i) background count (rate)     1   Do not accept:
                                            ‘background radiation’ alone
        (ii) 60 days                    1   Unit must be stated
                                            ±5 days tolerance

        (iii) 3 half-lives identified (1) 2 Or consistent with (a)(ii)

            (3 × 60 days)
                                            Accept:
            180 days               (1)      evidence of halving three times for
                                            the first mark, eg 1½¼⅛
                                            Accept use of graph to determine
                                            the time between a value and ⅛^{t}^{h} of
                                            that value, tolerance of ±5 days.

        (iv) 4000 counts per minute     1   Or consistent with (a)(ii)

                                            Alternative Method:

                                            Extrapolation of graph
                                            Accept any value between 3800 and
                                            4800 counts per minute, consistent
                                            with extrapolated line.
                                            There must be evidence of
                                            extrapolation to award the mark for
                                            this method.

                                            Accept:
                                            cpm for counts per minute

                                            Unit must be stated.

    (b)     any suitable use            1   Must be a use of nuclear radiation

            (eg tracers/sterilisation/smoke Accept:
            detectors/measuring thickness of generation of electricity
            paper)
                                            Do not accept: answers relating to
                                            killing cancer cells or radiotherapy,
                                            as this is the use given in the stem
                                            of the question, but would not
                                            negate a correct response.

                                            Do not accept:
                                            ‘power’ alone
                                            ‘generation of power’ alone
                                            ‘power source’ alone
                                            ‘nuclear bombs/weapons’ alone

                                            Apply +/- rule for surplus answers

                       [END OF MARKING INSTRUCTIONS]

                               page 28