2023 Higher Physics - Paper 2 marking instructions

Source: Scottish Qualifications Authority (SQA) / Qualifications Scotland. This is a StemInteract HTML companion, not an official HTML edition. Selectable text is supplied alongside original page images. Use the images or original PDF for equations, powers, fractions, vector notation, tables and diagrams; text extraction cannot fully preserve mathematical layout.

Jump to a question

PDF page 1

Original 2023 Higher Physics - Paper 2 marking instructions, PDF page 1; open the image for mathematical layout and diagrams.
Original page image: preserves diagrams, equations, tables and symbols.
Selectable page text
National

                  Qualifications
                  2023

                           2023   Physics

                         Higher    Paper   2

                Finalised   Marking    Instructions

© Scottish Qualifications Authority 2023

These marking instructions have been prepared by examination teams for use by SQA appointed
markers when marking external course assessments. The information in this document may be
reproduced in support of SQA qualifications only on a noncommercial basis. If it is reproduced, SQA
must be clearly acknowledged as the source. If it is to be reproduced for any other purpose, written
permission must be obtained from permissions@sqa.org.uk.

PDF page 2

Original 2023 Higher Physics - Paper 2 marking instructions, PDF page 2; open the image for mathematical layout and diagrams.
Original page image: preserves diagrams, equations, tables and symbols.
Selectable page text
General marking principles for Physics Higher

This information is provided to help you understand the general principles you must apply when
marking candidate responses to questions in this paper. These principles must be read in conjunction
with the detailed marking instructions, which identify the key features required in candidate
responses.

(a) Marks for each candidate response must always be assigned in line with these marking principles,
    the Physics: general marking principles (GMPs) (Physics: general marking principles - National 3
    to Advanced Higher (sqa.org.uk)) and the detailed marking instructions for this assessment.

(b) Marking should always be positive. This means that, for each candidate response, marks are
    accumulated for the demonstration of relevant skills, knowledge and understanding: they are
    not deducted from a maximum on the basis of errors or omissions.

(c) If a specific candidate response does not seem to be covered by either the principles or detailed
    marking instructions, and you are uncertain how to assess it, you must seek guidance from your
    team leader.

(d) Where a candidate answers part of a question incorrectly and carries the incorrect answer
    forward in the following part, award marks if the incorrect answer has then been used correctly
    in the subsequent part or ‘follow-on’. (GMP 16)

(e) Award marks for non-standard symbols where the symbols are defined and the relationship is
    correct, or where the substitution shows that the relationship used is correct. This must be clear
    and unambiguous. (GMP 20)

(f) Award full marks for a correct final answer (including units if required) on its own, unless a
    numerical question specifically requires evidence of working to be shown, eg in a ‘show’
    question. (GMP 1)

(g) Award marks where a diagram or sketch conveys correctly the response required by the
    question. It will usually require clear and correct labels (or the use of standard symbols). (GMP
    19)

(h) Marks are allocated for knowledge of relevant relationships alone. Do not award a mark when a
    candidate writes down several relationships and does not select the correct one to continue
    with, for example by substituting values. (GMP 1c)

(i) Do not award marks if a ‘magic triangle’ (eg) is the only statement in a candidate’s

    response. To gain the mark, the correct relationship must be stated, for example V = IR or
       V
    R=  . (GMP 2)
       I
(j) In rounding to an expected number of significant figures, award the mark for responses that have
    up to two figures more or one figure less than the number in the data with the fewest significant
    figures. (GMP 6)
                                
    (Note: the use of a recurrence dot, eg 0.6, would imply an infinite number of significant figures
    and would therefore not be acceptable.)

                                page 02

PDF page 3

Original 2023 Higher Physics - Paper 2 marking instructions, PDF page 3; open the image for mathematical layout and diagrams.
Original page image: preserves diagrams, equations, tables and symbols.
Selectable page text
(k) The incorrect spelling of technical terms should usually be ignored and candidates should be

    awarded the relevant mark, provided that answers can be interpreted and understood without
    any doubt as to the meaning.
    Where there is ambiguity, do not award the mark. Two specific examples of this would be when
    the candidate uses a term:

       • that might be interpreted as reflection, refraction or diffraction, eg ‘defraction’
       • that might be interpreted as either fission or fusion, eg ‘fussion’
    The spelling of these words is similar, but the words have totally different meanings. If the
    spelling (or handwriting) in an answer makes it difficult for you to interpret a candidate’s
    intention, then do not award the mark. (GMP 22)

(l) Marks are awarded only for a valid response to the question asked. For example, in response to
    questions that ask candidates to:
    • identify, name, give, or state, they need only name or present in brief form.

    • describe, they must provide a statement or structure of characteristics and/or features.
    • explain, they must relate cause and effect and/or make relationships between things clear.

    • determine or calculate, they must determine a number from given facts, figures or
      information.
    • estimate, they must determine an approximate value for something.

    • justify, they must give reasons to support their suggestions or conclusions. For example this
      might be by identifying an appropriate relationship and the effect of changing variables.
    • show that, they must use physics [and mathematics] to prove something, for example a given
      value – all steps, including the stated answer, must be shown.

    • predict, they must suggest what may happen based on available information.
    • suggest, they must apply their knowledge and understanding of physics to a new situation. A
      number of responses are acceptable: award marks for any suggestions that are supported by
      knowledge and understanding of physics.

    • use their knowledge of physics or aspect of physics to comment on, they must apply their
      skills, knowledge and understanding to respond appropriately to the problem/
      situation presented (for example by making a statement of principle(s) involved and/or a
      relationship or equation, and applying these to respond to the problem/situation). Candidates
      are given credit for the breadth and/or depth of their conceptual understanding.

Standard three marker
The examples over the page set out how to apportion marks to answers requiring calculations. These
are the ‘standard three marker’ type of questions.
Award full marks for a correct answer to a numerical question, even if the steps are not shown
explicitly, unless it specifically requires evidence of working to be shown.
For some questions requiring numerical calculations, there may be alternative methods
(eg alternative relationships) that would lead to a correct answer.

Sometimes, a question requires a calculation that does not fit into the ‘standard three marker’ type of
response. In these cases, the detailed marking instructions will contain guidance for marking the
question.
When marking partially correct answers, apportion individual marks as shown over the page.

                                page 03

PDF page 4

Original 2023 Higher Physics - Paper 2 marking instructions, PDF page 4; open the image for mathematical layout and diagrams.
Original page image: preserves diagrams, equations, tables and symbols.
Selectable page text
(l) Marking in calculations
    Example question
    The current in a resistor is 1·5 amperes when the potential difference across it is 7·5 volts.
    Calculate the resistance of the resistor. (3 marks)

       Example response Mark and comment

     1. V = IR          1 mark: relationship

       7.5 = 1.5R       1 mark: substitution
       R = 5.0 Ω        1 mark: correct answer

     2. 5.0 Ω           3 marks: correct answer
     3. 5.0             2 marks: unit missing

     4. 4.0 Ω           0 marks: no evidence, wrong answer

     5. __ Ω            0 marks: no working or final answer
     6.    V  7.5
        R = =    =4.0 Ω 2 marks: arithmetic error
           I  1.5
     7.    V
        R = =4.0 Ω      1 mark: relationship only
           I
     8.   V
        R=  =__Ω        1 mark: relationship only
           I
     9.    V  7.5
        R = =   = __Ω   2 marks: relationship and substitution, no final answer
           I  1.5
    10.   V   7.5
        R=  =   =4.0    2 marks: relationship and substitution, wrong answer
           I  1.5
    11.   V   1.5
        R=  =   =5.0 Ω  1 mark: relationship but wrong substitution
           I  7.5
    12.   V   75
        R=  =   =5.0 Ω  1 mark: relationship but wrong substitution
           I 1.5
    13.    I 1.5
        R=  =   =5.0 Ω  0 marks: wrong relationship
          V   7.5
    14. V = IR
       7.5 = 1.5 × R
       R = 0.2 Ω        2 marks: relationship and substitution, arithmetic error
    15. V = IR
           I  1.5
        R=  =   =0.2 Ω  1 mark: relationship correct but wrong rearrangement of
          V   7.5              symbols

                                page 04

PDF page 5

Paper 2, Question 1
Original 2023 Higher Physics - Paper 2 marking instructions, PDF page 5; open the image for mathematical layout and diagrams.
Original page image: preserves diagrams, equations, tables and symbols.
Selectable page text
Marking instructions for each question

                                        Max
   Question       Expected response               Additional guidance
                                       mark
 1.  (a)    v² =u² +2as            (1)   3  Accept: 32, 31.50, 31.502
            0² =(13.4)² +2×−2.85×s  (1)
                                            u and a must have opposite signs.
             s =31.5 m             (1)
                                            Alternative methods:
                                            Both relationships    (1)
                                            Both substitutions    (1)
                                            Final answer          (1)
     (b)    v=u+at                 (1)   3  Or consistent with (a)

            0=13.4+(−2.85t)        (1)      Accept: 4.7, 4.702, 4.7018
            t =4.70 s              (1)
                                            u and a must have opposite signs.
                                            Alternative methods eg
                                               1
                                             s = (u+v)t     (1)
                                               2
                                                 1
                                            31.5=  (13.4+0)t (1)
                                                 2
                                            t =4.70 s       (1)

                                            For this method accept: 4.7, 4.701,
                                            4.7015

     (c)    Straight line with negative  2  Must be consistent with (b)
            gradient               (1)

                                            Second mark conditional on first
            Axes values            (1)
                                            mark

                                page 05

PDF page 6

Paper 2, Question 2
Original 2023 Higher Physics - Paper 2 marking instructions, PDF page 6; open the image for mathematical layout and diagrams.
Original page image: preserves diagrams, equations, tables and symbols.
Selectable page text
Max
  Question       Expected response               Additional guidance
                                      mark
2.  (a)     F = ma                (1)   2  SHOW
           125−(15+45) =(28+85)×a (1)
                                           Must show how both total mass and
            a =0.58 ms⁻²                   unbalanced force are arrived at.
    (b)                                 4  Accept: 30, 31.2, 31.24

            F =ma                  (1)     T =ma on its own – 0 marks.
            F =28×0.58             (1)

           ( F =Tension+Friction )

           28×0.58=Tension+(−15)
                                   (1)
           Tension=31 N            (1)

    (c)    (Tension) increases    (1)   2  JUSTIFY

           (Friction increases but) unbalanced/ Must be clear it is the unbalanced
           resultant force remains the same. force that remains constant.
                                  (1)      Accept: ‘F’ for unbalanced force

                                           Can be justified by calculation.

                               page 06

PDF page 7

Paper 2, Question 3
Original 2023 Higher Physics - Paper 2 marking instructions, PDF page 7; open the image for mathematical layout and diagrams.
Original page image: preserves diagrams, equations, tables and symbols.
Selectable page text
Max
  Question       Expected response               Additional guidance
                                      mark
3.  (a)    mₓuₓ +m_{y}u_{y} =mₓvₓ +m_{y}v_{y} (1) 3 Accept: 7, 7.03, 7.026
           (760×12.0)+(840×4.0)
                                           Equating the total momenta before
           =(760×vₓ)+(840×8.5)  (1)        and after             (1)
                                           All substitutions     (1)
           vₓ =7.0 ms⁻¹         (1)        Final answer          (1)
                                           If a direction is stated it must be to
                                           the right otherwise MAX 2 marks.

    (b)        1                       4   Or consistent with (a)
           Eₖ = mv²
               2
                                           1 mark for relationship
           Before
                                           1 mark for all substitutions
               1     1
           Eₖ = mₓuₓ²+ m_{y}u_{y}²         1 mark for both total kinetic
               2     2
                                           energies
               1           1               1 mark for correct final statement
           Eₖ =( ×760×12.0²)+( ×840×4.0²)
               2          2
           Eₖ =61440 (J)
                                           Suspend significant figure rule for
            After
                                           calculated values of total kinetic
               1     1
           Eₖ = mₓvₓ²+ m_{y}v_{y}²         energies in this question.
               2     2
               1          1
           Eₖ =( ×760×7.0²)+( ×840×8.5²)
               2          2
           Eₖ =48965 (J)
                                           Kinetic energy is lost.(Therefore
                                           inelastic.)
           (Total) E before is greater than
           (total) E^{k} after, (the collision is
                                           E before ≠ E after is insufficient.
           inelastic)^{k}.                  k       k
    (c)    Ft =mv−mu              (1)  3   Accept: 5, 4.61, 4.610
           F×0.82=(840×8.5)−(840×4.0) (1)
                                           Accept: Impulse = mv − mu
           F =4.6×10³ N           (1)
                                           u and v must be substituted
                                           correctly
                                           If the force that car Y exerts on car
                                           X is calculated, then there must be a
                                           statement that the forces have
                                           equal magnitude for final mark,
                                           otherwise MAX 2 marks.
                                           For this method –
                                           Accept: 5, 4.63, 4.634 (when v = 7.0)
                                           Or consistent with (a)
    (d)    (During a collision the tyre wall will) 2 INDEPENDENT MARKS
           increase the time of contact
           (between the car and the wall). (1) Accept: time/duration of collision
           (this will) reduce the (magnitude of Accept: ‘rate of change in
           the) force (experienced by the  momentum’ for force.
           driver).               (1)
                               page 07

PDF page 8

Paper 2, Question 4
Original 2023 Higher Physics - Paper 2 marking instructions, PDF page 8; open the image for mathematical layout and diagrams.
Original page image: preserves diagrams, equations, tables and symbols.
Selectable page text
Max
  Question       Expected response               Additional guidance
                                      mark
4.  (a)    0.5 m s⁻¹                    1  Ignore minus sign if given in final
                                           answer.
    (b)    1.8 m s⁻¹                    1  Ignore minus sign if given in final
                                           answer.

    (c) (i)                             2  JUSTIFY

           3.00 × 10⁸ m s⁻¹ or c  (1)      Accept: 3 × 10⁸ m s⁻¹

                                           If the numerical value for speed
                                           is given, then unit is required,
                                           otherwise 0 marks.

                                           Accept:
           Speed of light is the same for all Speed of light is the same in all
           observers              (1)      (inertial) frames of reference or
                                           equivalent.

        (ii)                            3  Accept: 62, 61.90, 61.896
                  v²
           l′=l 1−              (1)
                  c
                                           Accept: l′=142 1−(0.9)²
                    0.9c²
           l′=142 1−            (1)
                     c 
           l′=61.9 m              (1)

                               page 08

PDF page 9

Paper 2, Question 5
Original 2023 Higher Physics - Paper 2 marking instructions, PDF page 9; open the image for mathematical layout and diagrams.
Original page image: preserves diagrams, equations, tables and symbols.
Selectable page text
Max
  Question       Expected response               Additional guidance
                                      mark
5.  (a) (i)       v                   3  Accept: 500, 484, 484.1
            fₒ = fₛ             (1)
                v±vₛ
                                          Accept:
                   340                          v 
            fₒ =440              (1)      fₒ = fₛ 
                  340−31                      v−vₛ
                                                     
            fₒ =480 Hz             (1)
        (ii)                            2  MUST JUSTIFY
           Less than              (1)      Accept: “It is less than”
                                           Do not accept: “Sound is less than”
                                           on its own.
           Statement that there are fewer  Accept: Waves or wave crests in
           wavefronts per second.          place of wavefronts.

           OR
                                           Can be justified by calculation.
           The wavefronts are further apart Significant figure rule suspended for
                                           this calculation.
           OR
           The wavelength increases        Can be justified by explaining the
                                           use of the ‘+’ version of the
           OR
                                           relationship.
           diagram showing wavefronts closer
           together ahead of the car and   In a diagram, there must be an
           further apart behind it. (1)    implication of direction of travel.
           or any similar response         Do not accept:
                                           Any answer that implies that the
                                           frequency/wavelength of the sound
                                           produced by the siren itself is
                                           changing.
    (b) (i) T = 0.5 s                   1

                               page 09

PDF page 10

Original 2023 Higher Physics - Paper 2 marking instructions, PDF page 10; open the image for mathematical layout and diagrams.
Original page image: preserves diagrams, equations, tables and symbols.
Selectable page text
Max
  Question       Expected response               Additional guidance
                                      mark
5.  (b) (ii)                            2  INDEPENDENT MARKS

           When the red LEDs are forward   Accept: The red and blue LEDs are
           biased the blue LEDs are reverse connected the opposite way round.
           biased (or vice versa). (1)

                                           LEDs will (only) conduct in one
           LEDs (only) light when forward
                                           direction
           biased                 (1)
                                           OR
                                           Red LEDs conduct during one half
                                           of the cycle the blue LEDs
                                           conduct during the other half of
                                           the cycle.
                                           Do not accept: ‘different direction’
                                           alone.

    (b) (iii) v= fλ                     4  Accept 3.2, 3.182, 3.1824
        (A)
           3.00×10⁸ = f ×625×10⁻⁹ (1)
                                           1 mark for both relationships
            E =hf                          1 mark for each substitution
           both relationships anywhere (1) 1 mark for final answer
                       3.00×10⁸ 
                                           Alternative method:
            E =6.63×10⁻³⁴×      (1)
                       625×10⁻⁹
                                           E =
                                              hc
                                                                   (1)
                                               λ
            E =3.18×10⁻¹⁹ J       (1)
                                                       3.00×10⁸ 
                                            E =6.63×10⁻³⁴×    (1),(1)
                                                       625×10⁻⁹ 
                                            E =3.18×10⁻¹⁹ J        (1)
                                           Do not accept:
                                            E₂ −E₁=hf
       (iii) The (energy) band gap in a blue LED 2 Accept: Converse arguments.
        (B) is greater.           (1)
                                           If no mention of band gap, 0 marks.
                                           Accept:
           The photons of blue light have more The photons of blue light have a
           energy (than the photons of red higher frequency (than the photons
           light).                (1)      of red light).
                                           OR
                                           The photons of blue light have a
                                           smaller wavelength (than the
                                           photons of red light).

                               page 10

PDF page 11

Paper 2, Question 6
Original 2023 Higher Physics - Paper 2 marking instructions, PDF page 11; open the image for mathematical layout and diagrams.
Original page image: preserves diagrams, equations, tables and symbols.
Selectable page text
Max
  Question       Expected response               Additional guidance
                                      mark
6.         Award 3 marks where the candidate 3 Candidates may use a variety of
           has demonstrated a good         physics arguments to answer this
           understanding of the physics    question.
           involved. They show a good      Award marks based on candidates
           comprehension of the physics of the demonstrating overall good,
           situation and provide a logically reasonable, limited, or no
           correct answer to the question  understanding.
           posed. This type of response might
           include a statement of the principles
           involved, a relationship or an
           equation, and the application of
           these to respond to the problem.
           The answer does not need to be
           ‘excellent’ or ‘complete’ for the
           candidate to gain full marks.
           Award 2 marks where the candidate
           has demonstrated a reasonable
           understanding of the physics
           involved. They make some
           statement(s) that are relevant to the
           situation, showing that they have
           understood the problem.

           Award 1 mark where the candidate
           has demonstrated a limited
           understanding of the physics
           involved. They make some
           statement(s) that are relevant to the
           situation, showing that they have
           understood at least a little of the
           physics within the problem.

           Award 0 marks where the candidate
           has not demonstrated an
           understanding of the physics
           involved. There is no evidence that
           they have recognised the area of
           physics involved, or they have not
           given any statement of a relevant
           physics principle. Award this mark
           also if the candidate merely restates
           the physics given in the question.

                               page 11

PDF page 12

Paper 2, Question 7
Original 2023 Higher Physics - Paper 2 marking instructions, PDF page 12; open the image for mathematical layout and diagrams.
Original page image: preserves diagrams, equations, tables and symbols.
Selectable page text
Max
  Question        Expected response               Additional guidance
                                       mark
7.  (a) (i) (P =) 53                    1
        (A)

        (i) Iodine                      1   Or consistent with (a)(i)(A)
        (B)
                                            Accept: I
        (ii) Lepton(s)                  1
        (A)

        (ii) Weak (nuclear force)       1
        (B)

    (b) (i)                             5   Accept: 2.5, 2.474, 2.4740

           W =QV                   (1)       W =QV anywhere
           W =1.60×10⁻¹⁹×32.0×10³  (1)

               1                                1
            Eₖ = mv²               (1)       Eₖ = mv² anywhere
               2                                2
           1.60×10⁻¹⁹×32.0×10³
                                   (1)
           =0.5×1.673×10⁻²⁷×v²
           v=2.47×10⁶ m s⁻¹        (1)

        (ii) To ensure the electric field is always 1 To ensure the protons accelerate
           in the correct direction.        in the correct direction.

           OR                               Do not accept:
                                            same direction
           To ensure the force acting on a
           proton is always in the correct
           direction (as it crosses the gap).

    (c)    Up the page                  1   Accept: up/upwards/towards top
                                            of the page

                                            Arrow drawn pointing up the page
                                            is acceptable.

                                            If upwards arrow is drawn on the
                                            original diagram, it must be on the
                                            right-hand edge.
                                            The path of the particle on its own
                                            is not acceptable.

                               page 12

PDF page 13

Paper 2, Question 8
Original 2023 Higher Physics - Paper 2 marking instructions, PDF page 13; open the image for mathematical layout and diagrams.
Original page image: preserves diagrams, equations, tables and symbols.
Selectable page text
Max
  Question        Expected response               Additional guidance
                                       mark
8.  (a)                                 2   Any mention of laser - 0 marks.

                                            INDEPENDENT MARKS

           Apparatus               (1)      Must have either name or a
                                            labelled diagram of all measuring
                                            instruments.

                                            Do not accept:
                                            light sensor on its own for
           Method used to collect data (1)  instrument to measure irradiance.
                                            Ignore any mention of analysis of
                                            data.

    (b) (i) The power per unit area (incident on 1 Accept:
           a surface)                       power per square metre/power per
                                            metre squared/(m²)

                                            Do not accept: watts per square
                                            metre

                               page 13

PDF page 14

Original 2023 Higher Physics - Paper 2 marking instructions, PDF page 14; open the image for mathematical layout and diagrams.
Original page image: preserves diagrams, equations, tables and symbols.
Selectable page text
Max
  Question        Expected response               Additional guidance
                                       mark
8.  (b) (ii) 142 × 0.200² = 5.68        3   If only 4 sets of data used correctly
           63.1 × 0.300² = 5.68             then maximum 2 marks.
           35.5 × 0.400² = 5.68
                                            If only 3 sets of data used correctly
           22.7 × 0.500² = 5.68
                                            then maximum 1 mark (for
           15.8 × 0.600² = 5.69    (2)
                                            relationship).
                                            If only 1 or 2 sets of data used
                                            correctly, award 0 marks.
                                            Must be clear how the candidate
           statement of                     has used the data to obtain the
            I×d² =constant                  relationship.
           OR                               Accept: I×d² =5.68
               1                            Ignore inappropriate averaging in
            I ∝                   (1)
              d²                            this case.

                                            The ‘statement’ mark is only
                                            available if consistent with the
                                            calculations shown.
                                             I₁d₁² = I₂d₂²is insufficient on its
                                            own for statement of relationship.

                                             I×d² =k is insufficient on its own
                                            for statement of relationship.

                                            Graphical method:
                                            Graph drawn correctly  (1)
                                            Line of best fit through origin (1)
                                            Statement of relationship. (1)

                                            A sketch graph is not acceptable.

    (c)    Area increases          (1)  2   ‘light spreads out’ is insufficient
                                            for ‘area increases’
           Power remains the same  (1)
                                            Accept alternative explanation,
                                            provided the candidate refers to
                                            irradiance on light detector:
                                            Area remains the same  (1)
                                            (Incident) power decreases (1)

                               page 14

PDF page 15

Paper 2, Question 9
Original 2023 Higher Physics - Paper 2 marking instructions, PDF page 15; open the image for mathematical layout and diagrams.
Original page image: preserves diagrams, equations, tables and symbols.
Selectable page text
Max
  Question       Expected response                Additional guidance
                                       mark
9.         Award 3 marks where the candidate 3 Candidates may use a variety of
           has demonstrated a good          physics arguments to answer this
           understanding of the physics     question.
           involved. They show a good       Award marks based on candidates
           comprehension of the physics of the demonstrating overall good,
           situation and provide a logically reasonable, limited, or no
           correct answer to the question   understanding.
           posed. This type of response might
           include a statement of the principles
           involved, a relationship or an
           equation, and the application of
           these to respond to the problem.
           The answer does not need to be
           ‘excellent’ or ‘complete’ for the
           candidate to gain full marks.
           Award 2 marks where the candidate
           has demonstrated a reasonable
           understanding of the physics
           involved. They make some
           statement(s) that are relevant to the
           situation, showing that they have
           understood the problem.

           Award 1 mark where the candidate
           has demonstrated a limited
           understanding of the physics
           involved. They make some
           statement(s) that are relevant to the
           situation, showing that they have
           understood at least a little of the
           physics within the problem.

           Award 0 marks where the candidate
           has not demonstrated an
           understanding of the physics
           involved. There is no evidence that
           they have recognised the area of
           physics involved, or they have not
           given any statement of a relevant
           physics principle. Award this mark
           also if the candidate merely restates
           the physics given in the question.

                               page 15

PDF page 16

Paper 2, Question 10
Original 2023 Higher Physics - Paper 2 marking instructions, PDF page 16; open the image for mathematical layout and diagrams.
Original page image: preserves diagrams, equations, tables and symbols.
Selectable page text
Max
  Question       Expected response               Additional guidance
                                      mark
10. (a)    A (central) positively charged 1 Do not accept:
           nucleus.                        Atom is mainly empty space.
           OR                              Nucleus is small compared to size of
           When an electron moves from one atom.
           state to another, the energy lost or Any statement referring to photons
           gained is done so ONLY in very  and photon frequency is a
           specific amounts of energy.     consequence, not a feature.
           OR
           Each line in a spectrum is produced
           when an electron moves from one
           energy level/orbit/shell to another.
    (b) (i) If an electron is in an excited state it 2 Accept:
           can return to a lower energy level. When an electron drops down a level
           When it does this, it emits a photon. it releases energy.
                                   (1)

           Different transitions produce   If absorption described - 0 marks.
           different lines/ frequencies (of
           photons).              (1)

        (ii) (For the brighter lines) more 2 INDEPENDENT MARKS
           electrons are making those
           transitions (per second).       Do not accept: greater brightness
                                   (1)     due to greater frequency/energy of
                                           the photons.
           (Therefore), there are more photons
           (per second) emitted (of that
                                           ‘More electrons release more
           specific energy and so produce
                                           photons’ on its own – MAX 1 mark
           brighter lines).       (1)
    (c) (i) 10                          1
        (ii) E₂ −E₁=hf            (1)   3  Accept: 6.9, 6.906, 6.9065
           −0.871×10⁻¹⁹−(−5.45×10⁻¹⁹)=6.63×10⁻³⁴× f Accept:(∆)E=hf
                                           OR
                                  (1)
                                            E₄ −E₁ =hf
            f =6.91×10¹⁴ Hz       (1)
                                           Note: ∆E =4.579×10⁻¹⁹ (J)
                                           Accept:
                                           5.45×10⁻¹⁹−0.871×10⁻¹⁹ =6.63×10⁻³⁴× f
                                           for energy substitution mark

                                           If 0.871×10⁻¹⁹−5.45×10⁻¹⁹ is shown for
                                           ΔE, maximum (1 mark) for
                                           relationship.

        (ii) 486 nm               (1)   1  Accept:
        (B)
                                            4.86×10⁻⁷ m

                               page 16

PDF page 17

Original 2023 Higher Physics - Paper 2 marking instructions, PDF page 17; open the image for mathematical layout and diagrams.
Original page image: preserves diagrams, equations, tables and symbols.
Selectable page text
Max
  Question       Expected response               Additional guidance
                                      mark
10. (c) (ii)                            5  Or consistent with (c)(ii)(B)
        (C)
                                           Accept: 4.9, 4.933, 4.9332

              v                               v
            z =                   (1)       z =
                                                   where, 1 mark
              c                               c ^{a}ⁿ^{y}
              4.52×10⁶
            z =                   (1)
              3.00×10⁸
              λₒ − λᵣ                          λₒ − λᵣ
            z =                    (1)      z =       anywhere, 1 mark
                λᵣ                              λᵣ
            4.52×10⁶ λₒ −486×10⁻⁹
                   =               (1)     substitution of 486 × 10⁻⁹ (1)
            3.00×10⁸  486×10⁻⁹
                                           Accept: 486
                                           Alternative method:
            λₒ = 4.93×10⁻⁷ m      (1)       v λₒ − λᵣ
                                             =
                                            c   λᵣ
                                            4.52×10⁶ λₒ −486
                                                   =
                                            3.00×10⁸  486
                                            λₒ = 4.93×10⁻⁷ m
                                           Equating formula,     (2)
                                           Substitution of v and c (1)
                                           Substitution of λ     (1)
                                                      r
                                           Final answer          (1)

                               page 17

PDF page 18

Paper 2, Question 11
Original 2023 Higher Physics - Paper 2 marking instructions, PDF page 18; open the image for mathematical layout and diagrams.
Original page image: preserves diagrams, equations, tables and symbols.
Selectable page text
Max
  Question       Expected response               Additional guidance
                                      mark
11. (a) (i)   sinθ₁                     3  Accept: 23, 22.59, 22.592
           n=                      (1)
              sinθ
                                           Accept:
           1.53=
                si²n36.0
                                   (1)      n₂ = sinθ₁            (1)
                 sinθ₂
                                            n₁ sinθ
           θ₂ =22.6°              (1)       1.53 sin²36.0
                                               =                 (1)
                                             1   sinθ₂
                                           θ₂ =22.6°              (1)
        (ii)                            2  Or consistent with (a)(i)
           180−60−[90−22.6]
                                   (1)
           (=52.6°)
           (90−52.6=B)                     Value must be given to 1 decimal
                                           place or consistent with the number
           B=37.4°                (1)
                                           of decimal places in answer to (a)(i)
    (b) (i) The angle of incidence that produces 1 Accept a description of the incident
           an angle of refraction of 90°.  ray as an alternative to the word
                                           ‘incidence’.
                                           Do not accept:
                                           The minimum angle of incidence
                                           that causes total internal reflection.
        (ii)     1                      3  Accept: 41, 40.81, 40.813
           sinθ_{c} =             (1)
                 n
                  1
           sinθ_{c} =             (1)
                 1.53
           θ_{c} =40.8°           (1)

                               page 18

PDF page 19

Original 2023 Higher Physics - Paper 2 marking instructions, PDF page 19; open the image for mathematical layout and diagrams.
Original page image: preserves diagrams, equations, tables and symbols.
Selectable page text
Max
   Question       Expected response               Additional guidance
                                       mark
11.  (c)                                 3  or consistent with (a)(ii) and/or
                                            (b)(ii)
            Emergent ray drawn at an angle
            greater than angle B   (1)      Accept: 68, 68.32, 68.324

               sinθ₁ 
            n=     
               sinθ₂ 
                  sinθ₁
            1.53=                  (1)
                 sin37.4
            ( θ₁=68.3°)

            calculated angle correctly shown on Ignore any partially reflected rays.
            diagram                (1)
                                            If (a)(ii) has a greater angle than
                                            (b)(ii) then the total internal
                                            reflection would be correct

                                            Internally reflected ray drawn (1)
                                            Angle of reflection approximately
                                            equal to angle B       (1)
                                            Value for angle of reflection shown
                                            on diagram consistent with (a)(ii) (1)

                                            Ignore any further refraction at
                                            other glass-air boundaries.

                                page 19

PDF page 20

Paper 2, Question 12
Original 2023 Higher Physics - Paper 2 marking instructions, PDF page 20; open the image for mathematical layout and diagrams.
Original page image: preserves diagrams, equations, tables and symbols.
Selectable page text
Max
  Question       Expected response               Additional guidance
                                      mark
12. (a) (i)  1  1  1                  5  Accept: 9, 9.12, 9.120
              =  +   
           R_{T} R₁ R₂ 
            1   1  1 
              =  +   
           R_{T} 16 16
            R_{T}
              =8(
                 Ω
                  )
                                   (1)
            R=( (8+16)=)24(
                         Ω
                          )
                                   (1)     24 (Ω) anywhere 2 marks
           V = IR                  (1)     V = IR anywhere – 1 mark
           V =0.38×24              (1)
           V =9.1 V                (1)
                                           Alternative methods
                                           2 marks for 24 (Ω) anywhere
                                           1 mark for all relationships
                                           1 mark for all substitutions
                                           1 mark for final answer
        (ii) E =V +Ir             (1)   3  Or consistent with a(i)*
                                           Accept: 8, 7.63, 7.632
           12=9.1+(0.38×r)        (1)
                                           *If V = 12 V then max 1 mark for
                                           relationship.
           r =7.6Ω                (1)
                                           Alternative method:
                                            E = I ( R+r )        (1)
                                           12=0.38(24+r )        (1)
                                            r =7.6Ω              (1)
                                           For this method
                                           accept: 8, 7.58, 7.579
                                           for ‘lost volts’ accept:
                                           V = Ir
                                           V = IR

                               page 20

PDF page 21

Original 2023 Higher Physics - Paper 2 marking instructions, PDF page 21; open the image for mathematical layout and diagrams.
Original page image: preserves diagrams, equations, tables and symbols.
Selectable page text
Max
  Question       Expected response               Additional guidance
                                      mark
12. (a) (iii) P= I²R               (1)  3  Or consistent with (a)(i) and/or(a)(ii)

            P =0.38²×7.6           (1)     Accept: 1, 1.10, 1.097
            P =1.1 W               (1)
                                           Accept: P = I²r

                                           Alternative methods:
                                            P= IV                (1)
                                            P=0.38×(12−9.1)      (1)
                                            P=1.1 W              (1)

                                           OR

                                              V²
                                            P =                  (1)
                                               R
                                              (12−9.1)²
                                            P=                   (1)
                                                 7.6

                                            P=1.1 W              (1)
    (b)    (Power dissipated) less than (1) 2 MUST JUSTIFY

                                           Accept:
           (Total circuit resistance increases), current decreases, and lost volts
                                           decreases.
           current decreases, internal
           resistance stays the same (1)   lost volts decreases, and internal
                                           resistance stays the same.

                               page 21

PDF page 22

Paper 2, Question 13
Original 2023 Higher Physics - Paper 2 marking instructions, PDF page 22; open the image for mathematical layout and diagrams.
Original page image: preserves diagrams, equations, tables and symbols.
Selectable page text
Max
  Question       Expected response               Additional guidance
                                      mark
13. (a) (i)   Q                         3  Accept: 20, 24.0, 24.00
           C =                    (1)
              V
              136.8×10⁻³
           C =                    (1)
                 5.7
           C =24×10⁻³ F           (1)
        (ii)                            3  Or consistent with (a)(i)

                                           Suspend significant figures rule in
                                           this question.
                  0.1  
           %ΔV  =  ×100 =1.8( % ) (1)
                 5.7                     Anywhere
                1.8
            ΔC =  ×24×10⁻³        (1)
               100                         Accept rounding at an intermediate
                                           stage in this question.
            ΔC =4×10⁻⁴ F          (1)

                                           Alternative method:
                                                 0.1
                                            ΔV =   =0.018 anywhere (1)
                                                5.7
                                                0.1
                                            ΔC =  ×24×10⁻³        (1)
                                                5.7
                                            ΔC =4×10⁻⁴ F          (1)
    (b)                                 2  Or consistent with (a)(i)
           (t =5RC)
                                           Accept: 2000
           t =5×15×10³×24×10⁻³    (1)
           t =1800 s              (1)

                               page 22

PDF page 23

Paper 2, Question 14
Original 2023 Higher Physics - Paper 2 marking instructions, PDF page 23; open the image for mathematical layout and diagrams.
Original page image: preserves diagrams, equations, tables and symbols.
Selectable page text
Max
  Question       Expected response               Additional guidance
                                      mark
14. (a)    Axes appropriately labelled (quantity 3 If the origin is shown the scale must
           and units) and axes linearly scaled either be continuous, or the axis
                                  (1)      must be ‘broken’.
           [Allow for axes starting at zero or Otherwise, maximum 2 marks.
           broken axes or an appropriate value]
                                           If non-linear scale is used over the
           Data points plotted accurately (1) range of the data on either axis eg
                                           values from the table are used as
           Appropriate line of best-fit (1) the scale points. (0) marks

                                           Do not penalise if candidates plot
                                           frequency against switch on voltage.

                                           Accuracy of plotting should be easily
                                           checkable with the scale chosen.
                                           An appropriate scale to allow the
                                           accuracy of plotting to be checked
                                           must be linear over the range of the
                                           data.
    (b)    Choosing 2 points on their line (1) 2 Must be consistent with graph drawn
                                           for (a).
           Calculate gradient:    (1)

                                           Candidates are asked to calculate
           (min 1 sig fig, max 4 sig figs) the gradient of their graph.

           (Gradient works out as approx.  Tolerance required depending upon
           5.0 ×10⁻¹⁵)                     best fit line drawn by the candidate.

                                           If candidates use values from the
                                           table, these points must lie on their
                                           line.

                                           If (×10¹⁴) is not accounted for in the
                                           final answer, maximum 1 mark
                                           unless this being omitted is
                                           consistent with the graph drawn in
                                           (a).

                                           A unit is not required in the final
                                           answer, but if stated it must be
                                           correct.

                                           If candidate has a non-linear scale
                                           over the range of the values used in
                                           the substitution, (0) marks.

                                           If candidate has drawn a ‘dot to dot’

                                           graph or no line, (0) marks.

                               page 23

PDF page 24

Original 2023 Higher Physics - Paper 2 marking instructions, PDF page 24; open the image for mathematical layout and diagrams.
Original page image: preserves diagrams, equations, tables and symbols.
Selectable page text
Max
  Question       Expected response               Additional guidance
                                      mark
14. (c)                                 2  Must be consistent with (b)
           (h=e×gradient)
           h=1.60×10⁻¹⁹×5.0×10⁻¹⁵ (1)      Must substitute the gradient of their
                                           graph, and not a single data point.
           h= 8.0×10⁻³⁴ Js        (1)
                                           If a single data point is substituted
                                           into in the calculation, award (0)
                                           marks

                                           Accept: correct alternative units

                                           If candidate has plotted frequency
                                           against switch on voltage, the
                                           formula becomes
                                                e   
                                           h=
                                                     
                                              gradient
                                              1.60×10⁻¹⁹
                                            h=                   (1)
                                               2.0×10¹⁴
                                            h= 8.0×10⁻³⁴ Js      (1)
    (d)    Repeat the measurements and take 1 Accept: ‘Average’ for ‘mean’
           the mean.                       Do not accept:
                                           ‘Repeat the experiment and take
           OR                              the mean’ on its own.

           Use a greater range of colours/ Accept:
           frequencies of LEDs.            Use more colours/frequencies of
                                           LEDs.
           OR
                                           Do not accept:
           Carry out experiment in a dark  Use more LEDs
           room/use a viewing tube to see  take more measurements on its own.
           when LED first emits light.

           OR

           Use a photodiode to detect when the
           LED lights/use an ammeter to detect
           when the circuit conducts.

                      [END OF MARKING INSTRUCTIONS]

                               page 24